Angular Module vs Library: Key Differences, Use Cases & Best Practices

Technogic profile picture By Technogic •
Thumbnail image for Angular Module vs Library: Key Differences, Use Cases & Best Practices

In the world of Angular development, structuring your application efficiently is key to long-term maintainability. As your codebase grows, the choice between using modules and libraries can have a lasting impact on everything—from build times to team collaboration and code reuse across projects.

With Angular's recent innovations like standalone components and Angular 18's streamlined tooling, you might even wonder: "Do we still need NgModules or libraries?" The short answer is yes—but the why and when have evolved. This blog dives deep into both concepts to help you decide the right abstraction for your needs.

Quick Comparison: Modules vs Libraries

Feature NgModule Angular Library
Purpose Organize code within an application Share reusable code across applications
Scope Application-level  Cross-application or workspace-level
Distribution Part of the application codebase Packaged and published (e.g., via npm)
Usage Imported via relative paths Installed and imported as packages
Versioning Tied to application version Independent semantic versioning
Typical Contents Components, directives, pipes, services Reusable components, services, utilities
Build Process Compiled with the application  Built separately, often using Angular Package Format (APF)

Deep Dive: Understanding NgModules

What is an NgModule?

An NgModule is a fundamental building block in Angular that helps organize related code. It declares which components, directives, and pipes belong to the module and can import other modules to use their exported functionalities. NgModules also provide a way to configure the dependency injection system.

Types of NgModules

  • Root Module: The main module that bootstraps the application.
  • Feature Modules: Encapsulate related functionalities, making the application more modular.
  • Shared Modules: Contain common components, directives, and pipes used across the application.
  • Routing Modules: Handle routing configuration for feature modules.

Even with Angular's push toward standalone components, NgModules are still valuable in 2025. For example, they're essential in server-side rendering, SSR hydration, and teams maintaining legacy or hybrid apps.

Why NgModules Still Matter

Despite the introduction of standalone components, NgModules remain relevant:

  • Lazy Loading: NgModules facilitate lazy loading, improving application performance.
  • Organization: They provide a structured way to organize complex applications.
  • Backward Compatibility: Many existing libraries and tools are built around NgModules.

Best Practices

  • Cohesion: Group related components and services together.
  • Reusability: Use Shared Modules to avoid code duplication.
  • Avoid Circular Dependencies: Structure modules to prevent circular references.
  • Lazy Load Feature Modules: Improve performance by loading modules only when needed.

Exploring Angular Libraries

What is an Angular Library?

An Angular Library is a collection of reusable components, services, and other code that can be shared across multiple applications. Unlike NgModules, libraries are packaged and distributed independently, often via npm. They cannot run on their own and must be imported into an application.

Anatomy of a Library

  • Has its own Angular project inside a workspace.
  • No main.ts or index.html; it’s not a runnable app.
  • Exposes public features via public-api.ts.

Creating a Library

To create a library:

  1. Generate a workspace without an initial application:
    ng new my-workspace --create-application=false
  2. Navigate into the workspace and generate a library:
    cd my-workspace
ng generate library my-lib

Angular Package Format (APF)

Angular Libraries adhere to the Angular Package Format (APF), ensuring compatibility and optimal performance. APF specifies how libraries should be structured and compiled, facilitating features like tree-shaking and Ivy compatibility.

Real-World Examples

  • Angular Material: A UI component library implementing Material Design.
  • ngx-translate: Provides internationalization support.
  • In-house Design Systems: Custom libraries tailored to specific organizational needs.

Maintaining a Library

  • Semantic Versioning: Clearly communicate changes and maintain compatibility.
  • Documentation: Provide clear usage instructions.
  • Testing: Ensure reliability across different applications.
  • Schematics: Offer installation and setup automation.

Embracing Standalone Components in Angular 18

Angular 18 introduced Standalone Components, allowing developers to create components without the need for NgModules.

Benefits

  • Simplified Structure: Reduces boilerplate code.
  • Enhanced Reusability: Components can be easily reused across projects.
  • Improved Performance: Better tree-shaking leads to smaller bundle sizes.
  • Incremental Adoption: Existing projects can gradually migrate to standalone components.

Considerations

  • Lazy Loading: While possible, it requires a different setup compared to NgModules.
  • Dependency Management: Dependencies are declared directly within the component.

Decision Matrix: When to Use What

Scenario Use NgModule Use Angular Library
Single Application Development YES NO
Multiple Applications Sharing Code NO YES
Need for Lazy Loading YES NO
Reusable UI Components Across Projects NO YES
Simplifying Application Structure YES NO
Publishing to npm or Sharing Externally NO YES

Best Practices

  • For NgModules:
    • Keep modules focused and cohesive.
    • Avoid circular dependencies.
    • Utilize lazy loading for feature modules.
  • For Angular Libraries:
    • Adhere to semantic versioning.
    • Provide comprehensive documentation.
    • Ensure compatibility with different Angular versions.
    • Use schematics to simplify installation and setup.

Common Pitfalls and Solutions

  • Pitfall: Including application-specific services in a library.
    • Solution: Keep libraries generic and free from application-specific logic.
  • Pitfall: Neglecting versioning and changelogs.
    • Solution: Implement semantic versioning and maintain a changelog for transparency.
  • Pitfall: Overcomplicating module structures.
    • Solution: Aim for simplicity and clarity in module organization.

Conclusion

Understanding the distinctions between NgModules and Angular Libraries is essential for architecting scalable and maintainable Angular applications. While NgModules provide a way to organize code within an application, Angular Libraries offer a means to share reusable code across multiple applications. With the introduction of Standalone Components in Angular 18, developers have more flexibility than ever to structure their applications effectively.

Choose the abstraction that aligns with your project's needs, and leverage the strengths of each to build robust Angular applications.

References